Engagement Rings

Where bended knee meets weak-in-the-knees, we’re here to help. Our diamond engagement rings are truly the mark of an adoring partner: So much more than beautiful, they connect your fiancé with a jeweler that will treat her—and you—like part of the Goodman Jewelers’ family every time you step foot in our store. Your fiancé will thank you for choosing a ring she loves from a jeweler well known for its ever-after care of customers.

A Forever Ring from a State Street Icon

We’re proud to be a part of the magic of Madison’s iconic State Street shopping district. As Madison’s oldest jewelry store, we’ve assisted thousands of people in finding perfect diamond engagement rings for their brides-to-be. It’s one of our greatest privileges as jewelers, and we’re the best at it:

  • Our selection of engagement rings range from classic solitaires to custom designs
  • We offer the most exquisite cuts from the highest quality of stones.
  • Our diamonds are conflict-free, brought from mine to market with social responsibility.
  • We offer layaway plans.

Come visit us and check out our exclusive selection of diamond engagement rings. We’ll help you dazzle her when you propose!

Diamond Ring Style Guide created by Casting House.

Naledi Collection – The Naledi Collection offers an exquisite jewelry collection of superb quality and beauty. A century of diamond cutting experience ensures each and every diamond is perfectly crafted. To view the Naledi Collection collection click here.

Cordova by Ron Rosen – Cordova is a multi-generational family owned and operated jewelry manufacturer, specializing in fashion and bridal design. To view the Cordova by Ron Rosen collection click here.

Whitehouse Brothers – Since 1898, Whitehouse Brothers has been crafting some of the America’s finest jewelry. Today the tradition continues, making one heirloom at a time. To view the Whitehouse Brothers collection click here, or view their Vintage and Wedding Ring catalogs

Sholdt –Inspired design meets incomparable craftsmanship. Designed to be unique works of art, master jewelers create each piece by hand using perfected methods and exacting standards. To view the Sholdt collection click here.

Hearts On Fire – Hearts On Fire engagement rings are crafted with the ultimate care and attention to detail, ensuring that every single ring has the brilliant sparkle that she has always dreamed of. To view the Hearts On Fire collection click here.

Gottlieb & Sons – Founded in 1949 Gottlieb & Sons has grown to be a leader in the international jewelry industry. Their goal is to create jewelry that reflects the high standards their family has set for over half a century. To view the Gottlieb & Sons collection click here.

Chatham Created Gems – To view the Chatham Created Gems collection click here.

Peter Storm – We carry engagement rings, bands, and the Tessuto Colori collection of fashion jewelry. To view the Peter Storm collection click here.